| Team | Record | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| 39Franciscan | 8-0 | +186 |
| 59Ohio | 5-2 | -37 |
| 96High Point | 4-4 | -19 |
| 97Carnegie Mellon | 3-5 | -175 |
| 101Shippensburg | 6-2 | +72 |
| 117Michigan State | 3-4 | -52 |
| 138Kentucky | 2-5 | -82 |
| 149Vanderbilt | 7-1 | +120 |
| 157Pittsburgh-B | 2-5 | -91 |
| 168Kalamazoo | 4-2 | +46 |
| 179Rochester | 5-2 | +75 |
| 205Xavier | 3-4 | -39 |
| 206Valparaiso | 5-2 | +46 |
| 227RIT | 4-3 | -79 |
| 250Dayton | 3-3 | -119 |
| 258Trine | 3-2 | -17 |
| 271West Virginia | 3-3 | -76 |
| 276Wright State | 3-4 | -86 |
| 284Miami | 2-5 | +356 |
| 296*Ohio Northern | 0-2 | -87 |
| 297Illinois-B | 4-4 | +79 |
| 303Northwestern-B | 3-4 | +106 |
| 316Case Western Reserve-B | 1-6 | -80 |
| 324*Allegheny | 0-4 | 0 |
| 330*Wooster-B | 0-5 | 0 |
| 338*Michigan State-B | 0-0 | 0 |